I agree at first glance they look good John. But, but.. sorry there has to be a but when I'm not sure about the finish..
But,, Sorry but I have had a closer look and the rollerball (second pen picture) looks as though the barrel is turned slightly off set. not sure if its the picture and how its taken but it look as though there is a overturned step on the top on one side and on opposites at the other end. There is always a but mate but whenever I look at it that is all I can see,,,,,,, Sorry...
And the only other point I would say is "wipe you big mit fingerprints off" before you take a picture... can see them on both pen ends .. Sorry Just me being picky...
But one thing I would say bis the fountain pen looks stunning and both pens presented really well..
You can banish me to the naughty boy room if you want too...