Jim,
I tried using micromesh till 12000, but the finish was still not good.
Maybe is the brand of polimer clay I used in past, but is too soft to mantain luster if you handle it too much.
CA will give some surface strenght and, imho, is easy to finish.
Look at this one:
View attachment 14287
I turned this for my mother 60th birthday and after little time of simple use, it was so scratched that looked almost grinded to 80 grit...
I had to strip it down, put it back on the late and give it a good CA finish.
Now, it's been used for a year and no scratch so far, its still good and shiny.
I think it depend on the brand of clay I used, but never tried other brand, so I can't really compare.
Have a good weekend
Francesco