Jewelry dish with finial Mk 2

[PhillH]

I did this one a while ago (Mk i) and I wasn't sure about the finial, bit fat and not too elegant.



So I thought I'd have another go so here is Mk II, Sycamore and Ebony, comments and crits welcome.

 

[Jim]

Yep, i have to admit that MKII looks more refined Phill, nice work indeed my friend ..

 

[Paul]

Yeah +1 for mk2

 

[brody2123]

The mk II is bloody spot on mate! Beautiful detail and balance. :bravo:

 

[Woody]

I like them both Phill well done my man

 

[Penpal]

Phill the thinner stem could allow the placing of rings over it better liked them both as well.

Kind regards Peter.

 

[chas_41_uk]

MII is definitely more refined, a very nice job

 

[paulm]

You're right Phil that MKII is very good but I also like MKI as well. MKII is progression to perfection.

 

[Lons]

That's realy nice Phill, I might have to have a go at one like that for the missus.

 

[ray7]

Like them both.

Ray

 

[Doug]

Lovely work Phill

 

[wm460]

I like them both Phill well done.

 

[bassethound]

Better but i like both!

 

[stevenw1963]

It is better Phil but still like them both, nice one (2)

 

[Gilliandrea]

They are both lovely, I'd happily have either on my side table

 

[Grump]

Does it pick up any more stations than the first???

 

[paulm]

Does it pick up any more stations than the first???

 

[Dalboy]

Very nice indeed the second with the thinner finial does look that much better

 

[PhillH]

Does it pick up any more stations than the first???

That could only have come from you


Thanks all for the kind words, much appreciated.

 

[Terry]

The second one for me Phill as it looks more balanced to me. A cracking bit of turning !!!