Hi cobalt, nice to see a stickmaker on here. I have used box elder in the past for a stick top and it works and finished nicely as all maples seem to. It was a bit bright for the types of sticks I was making though and I only used it once. That was probably about 15 years ago now! I also used to work in ramshorn.
I have done very little stickmaking over the past 10 years now as I lost over 500 seasoned stick blanks to woodworm (long story about a messy divorce and sticks being moved and stored in a wooden garage for 2 years before I could get them back...
). To add insult to injury, I lost all my picture files of made sticks when the PC was ruined by a lightning strike a few years back. I sort of gave up then.....:monkon:
The last ones I made were carved as one-piece sticks from hazel shanks still attached to large sections of thick branch. These were crooks and leg cleeks and were gifts for farmer friends. When I was carving seperate heads, most of my blanks came from
john boddy timber at Boroughbridge in N. Yorks.
I would spend hours and hours scouring the offcut bins there and came away with some superb pieces that were just big enough for a stick top but no use to the bowl turners..........:up:
It may be worth trying them for some box elder.
Cheers
Tom